click on image to zoom
Click to see additional views
May We Also Suggest
greeting card

View our selection of greeting cards.

You can select and personalize a greeting card at checkout.

Create-Your-Own Signature English Muffins - Four Packages

$21.99

$29.99$22.4925% OFF
Available to Ship Now

$41.99$31.4925% OFF
Available to Ship Now

ADD TO CART
QTY

PRODUCT DESCRIPTION

A perfect breakfast begins with our world famous, super thick signature English muffins. Their tiny air pockets help them crisp up perfectly in a toaster, and their satisfying extra thickness means you can top this bread treat with anything you choose.

Our flavor assortment includes tangy, savory and sweet choices. The Create-Your-Own Signature English Muffins invites you to select four of our many delicious flavors in any combination you choose. Every flavor is certified kosher. It's a great gift for anyone who enjoys scrumptious breakfast food. Four muffins per package.
  • Your choice—click the SELECT ITEMS button above to choose any 4 flavors from the selection box:
  • 1910 original recipe, 1 pkg. (4 muffins, 14.5 oz)
  • Cheddar cheese, 1 pkg. (4 muffins, 14.5 oz)
  • Cherry blossom, 1 pkg. (4 muffins, 15 oz)
  • Chocolate chip, 1 pkg. (4 muffins, 14.5 oz)
  • Cinnamon chip, 1 pkg. (4 muffins, 14.5 oz)
  • Cinnamon raisin, 1 pkg. (4 muffins, 14.5 oz)
  • Cranberry citrus, 1 pkg. (4 muffins, 15 oz)
  • Garlic herb, 1 pkg. (4 muffins, 14.5 oz)
  • Jalapeño cheddar, 1 pkg. (4 muffins, 14.5 oz)
  • Maple almond-flavored, 1 pkg. (4 muffins, 14.5 oz)
  • Multi-grain honey, 1 pkg. (4 muffins, 14.5 oz)
  • Pumpkin spice, 1 pkg. (4 muffins, 14.5 oz)
  • San Francisco-style sourdough, 1 pkg. (4 muffins, 14.5 oz)
  • Sweet harvest wheat, 1 pkg. (4 muffins, 14.5 oz)
  • Wild Maine blueberry, 1 pkg. (4 muffins, 14.5 oz)

Standard Shipping and Processing: $7.99

You may schedule delivery for a future arrival date at checkout.

For additional Shipping and Processing details click here.

REVIEW SNAPSHOT®

by PowerReviews
Wolferman'sCreate-Your-Own Signature English Muffins - Four Packages
 
4.3

(based on 30 reviews)

Ratings Distribution

  • 5 Stars

     

    (22)

  • 4 Stars

     

    (2)

  • 3 Stars

     

    (3)

  • 2 Stars

     

    (0)

  • 1 Stars

     

    (3)

83%

of respondents would recommend this to a friend.

Pros

  • Easy to prepare (8)
  • Flavorful (7)
  • Good value (6)
  • Well packaged (3)

Cons

  • Lacks flavor (4)

Best Uses

  • Anytime (5)
  • Gift (5)
  • Holidays (5)
  • Snack (4)
    • This was purchased as a:
    • Self Purchase

       

      73% 

      (8 reviews)

      Gift For Someone Else

       

      Sent to me as a Gift

       
    • Who would this item be appropriate for:
    • Family & Friends

       

      Business Clients

       

      Kids

       

      College Students

       

      Everyone

       

      38% 

      (5 reviews)

      Yourself

       

      Other

       

Most Liked Positive Review

 

TRADITIONAL OR ORGINAL ENG. MUFFINS

For several years our son in MD has been sending us Wolfermann's muffins. He sends several pkgs. to share with all the family and believe me we all have our favorites by...Read complete review

For several years our son in MD has been sending us Wolfermann's muffins. He sends several pkgs. to share with all the family and believe me we all have our favorites by now.

This year I decided I was going to order more. 1st mistake was not reading the instructions closely on the different sizes. I ordered 6 or 8 pkgs and they turned out to be too small for our toaster. My husband was upset with this... From now on I will order the 4 or 5 to a package. (large ones)

I love all the flavors but cinnamon raison and sour dough are my favs... followed by all the others...

I'd like to add that I also ordered the pineapple, white macadamia pound cake and it was awesome but when I warmed it in the microwave it was out of this world.

If you have any suggestions for toasting the small ones I'd love to have them. It costs too much to heat the oven for one or 2 people.

VS

Most Liked Negative Review

 

Not as good as they used to be

I have not had these muffins in years and decided to try them again. I ordered 3 flavors, blueberry, citrus and cherry blossom. Where is the fruit? Where is the flavor? You...Read complete review

I have not had these muffins in years and decided to try them again. I ordered 3 flavors, blueberry, citrus and cherry blossom. Where is the fruit? Where is the flavor? You could not taste the flavor difference selected, I could have ordered plain and there would not have been a difference. Doughie texture and no visible fruit inside as pictured. Even the smell of the opened bag is lacking of flavor. Very disappointing, I will not be ordering from Wolfermans again, I am glad I did not choose these for a gift I would have been embarrassed. I wanted to try them before ordering for a gift. I am a past customer and remember placing many orders for these muffins. Quality is not the same as it used to be......

Reviewed by 30 customers

Displaying reviews 1-10

Back to top

Previous | Next »

 
5.0

Best flavor and best texture ever!

By Mountain Girl

from Colorado

Pros

  • Flavorful
  • Good Value

Cons

    Best Uses

      Comments about Wolferman's Create-Your-Own Signature English Muffins - Four Packages:

      I used to be able to buy Wolferman's at my grocery store. No longer. But I bought them before that and will continue to buy them now. I gave some to family this year who are expecting a baby over the Holidays and got rave reviews---including the 3 year old who LOVES the minis. But the rest of us also love the big ones is all the wonderful flavors. Toasted with butter and/or jam. Great with a grated cheese and egg mixture toasted to make a 3-D quesadilla for lunch or for an appetizer! Great gift for yourselves! Great gift for family and friends!

      Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

       
      5.0

      60 year consumer of the 1910 Original Muffins

      By The Old Dog Walker

      from Holllady, UT

      Pros

      • Easy To Prepare
      • Flavorful
      • Good Value

      Cons

        Best Uses

        • Anytime
        • Coffeemuffinbutter
        • Entertaining
        • Gift
        • Holidays
        • Snack

        Comments about Wolferman's Create-Your-Own Signature English Muffins - Four Packages:

        I split my muffins with a fork, then obviously, I toast them and add butter. Eat in small bites, savor the flavors, warsh it all down with your very favorite cup of hot, fresh coffee.
        I have been fortunate enough to have a long history with "Wolfermans". Perhaps some of you may have also grown up in K.C. and maybe rode on the streetcar system to the downtown Wolfermans location?
        The "original" Wolfermans was a scaled back version of the current elegant provisioner in NYC. The Wolfermans store was beautiful, with dark wood paneling, carpeting and table settings befitting of an ocean liner. Dining tables were located on a wide, elevated walkway that encircled the perimeter from an open second floor. This arrangement allowed the for a relaxed meal and the opportunity for people watching from above. I believe the store was located on Grand or Walnut St. but I very well may be mistaken. I believe that Wolfermans has changed hands and certainly the location, several times. But the quality of the "Original 1910 English muffin" has not wavered. I order 3 originals and 1 Cheddar for myself at Christmas. And if I must, I share them (1) with my immediate family. Honestly they get one half a muffin each. If they start whining, then I relent and toast another one for them to share. This has been a long standing tradition in my life. I have gifted the 1910's to a number of friends-they absolutely love them.
        Please try the 1910 original signature muffin for yourself and or give to your friends. I have NEVER been disappointed with doing the same. (I do not do flavors, other than cheddar)

        Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

        (0 of 2 customers found this review helpful)

         
        3.0

        Disappointed

        By Florida resident

        from Southwest Florida

        Pros

        • Easy To Prepare

        Cons

        • Lacks Flavor
        • Poor Packaging
        • Poor Texture

        Best Uses

          Comments about Wolferman's Create-Your-Own Signature English Muffins - Four Packages:

          I received these muffins last year and decided to order some for myself. The flavor was not the same. Last year the muffins tasted like the scones I used to have as a child. This year they were tasteless.

          Service and delivery comments:

          The delivery took over a week. The package received was damaged and had been opened and reclosed with tape that was not secure. Air was able to get into the muffins.This may have impacted the flavor. I had ordered several gifts to be delivered to friends and family, I hope they will be delivered in better condition than the package I had sent to me

          Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

          (6 of 6 customers found this review helpful)

           
          5.0

          My favorite English Muffins!

          By Georgiagirl34

          from Greenville, SC

          See all my reviews

          Pros

          • Easy To Prepare
          • Flavorful
          • Good Value
          • Well Packaged

          Cons

            Best Uses

            • Add Flavor
            • Anytime
            • Gift
            • Holidays
            • Snack

            Comments about Wolferman's Create-Your-Own Signature English Muffins - Four Packages:

            These muffins are superior to any other muffin I have tried. I like the signature muffins Original flavor the best because I can add any topping. They are easy to split in half by just pulling them apart.

            Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

            (4 of 4 customers found this review helpful)

             
            4.0

            Mother's Day Gift

            By Mrs. HHH

            from Milton, MA

            Pros

            • Easy To Prepare
            • Good Value
            • Well Packaged

            Cons

            • Lacks Flavor

            Best Uses

            • Anytime
            • Gift
            • Holidays
            • Snack

            Comments about Wolferman's Create-Your-Own Signature English Muffins - Four Packages:

            First time purchase from Wolferman's. My niece recommended this website to me as I was looking for a Mother's Day gift for my mother and mother-in-law.
            Both recipients LOVED the selection of muffins we chose. We also bought a create-your-own 6 pack for our own house as well. The muffins are really good, there is no denying that. The only complaint I have is that a couple of the choices could have had a little more flavor and/or fruit(cinnamon raisin and blueberry). Other than that, they are delicious!!!

            Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

            (4 of 5 customers found this review helpful)

             
            5.0

            Delicious muffins!

            By Jennifer

            from Alameda, CA

            Pros

            • Easy To Prepare
            • Flavorful
            • Good Value

            Cons

              Best Uses

                Comments about Wolferman's Create-Your-Own Signature English Muffins - Four Packages:

                A wonderful person sent us a package of mixed English muffins, and they were the best ones I have ever had! The blueberry in particular were amazing!

                Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

                (2 of 3 customers found this review helpful)

                 
                3.0

                The jalapeño cheddar were too hot for me

                By Wavnut

                from Newark, Ohio

                Pros

                • Easy To Prepare

                Cons

                  Best Uses

                    Comments about Wolferman's Create-Your-Own Signature English Muffins - Four Packages:

                    I would like less heat and more cheese flavor in the jalapeño cheddar muffins.

                    Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

                    (4 of 7 customers found this review helpful)

                     
                    5.0

                    Great gift

                    By Sue

                    from Tacoma, WA

                    Pros

                    • Good Value

                    Cons

                      Best Uses

                        Comments about Wolferman's Create-Your-Own Signature English Muffins - Four Packages:

                        The person who received this gift said she is enjoying them very much.

                        Service and delivery comments:

                        Prompt delivery. Arrived when the tracking said it would. I had a holiday code for free shipping so it was a great value and time saver to have it delivered directly to my recipient.

                        Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

                        (6 of 9 customers found this review helpful)

                         
                        1.0

                        i would not order these again no flavor

                        By susiej

                        from orlando fl

                        Pros

                        • Taste Less

                        Cons

                        • Lacks Flavor

                        Best Uses

                        • Not Me

                        Comments about Wolferman's Create-Your-Own Signature English Muffins - Four Packages:

                        no flavor at all ordered cinn. chip blueberry cherry cranberry orange would not order again

                        Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

                        (4 of 5 customers found this review helpful)

                         
                        5.0

                        Awesome for Eggs Benedict!

                        By Scott

                        from Chicago, IL

                        Pros

                        • Flavorful
                        • Thick Perfect Crumb

                        Cons

                        • None

                        Best Uses

                        • Eggs Benedict

                        Comments about Wolferman's Create-Your-Own Signature English Muffins - Four Packages:

                        There is no better English muffin for Eggs Benedict than Wolferman's! We use them for special occasions such as our traditional family Christmas morning breakfast of Eggs Benedict. They are think, flavorful, and beautiful for such a special meal on such a special day!

                        Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

                        Displaying reviews 1-10

                        Back to top

                        Previous | Next »

                        Do you have questions about this product?

                        Get answers from real customers and in-house experts with AnswerBox.

                        6 Questions | 8 Answers
                        Displaying questions 1-6
                        • Q:

                          Hi,Sirs:
                          Do you have 41/2 inch size English muffins?
                          We want that size of them.

                          Thank you.
                          Water
                          Asked on 12/22/2015 by Water from Kansas city, mo

                          2 answers

                          • CUSTOMER CARE

                            A:

                            Walter, our Signature English Muffins are 3.25" in width by 1.5" in Height, and our Traditional English Muffins are 3.25" in width and .75" in Height.

                            Answered on 12/27/2015 by Customer Care from Medford, OR
                          • CUSTOMER CARE

                            A:

                            Walter, we have sent you an e-mail with the information you requested. It should arrive shortly.

                            Answered on 12/27/2015 by Customer Care from Medford, OR
                        • Q:

                          Under "Product Description" it shows about 14 different flavors, but when I click "Select Items" I only get a choice of 6 different flavors. Most of the flavors I want are not available to select. I can see the flavors are available elsewhere on the site, i.e., in larger gift baskets, so they are obviously in stock.

                          Is there any way to select from the full list of flavors when ordering this 4-pack?
                          Asked on 3/24/2015 by Matt from Boston, MA

                          1 answer

                          • CUSTOMER CARE

                            A:

                            Matt, there is a scroll bar in the center of the pop-up that appears when you click "Select Items". You can scroll down to view more selections. You can also call us at 1-800-999-1910 to place your order.

                            Answered on 3/25/2015 by Customer Care from Medford, OR
                        • Q:

                          Since it takes anywhere from 5-6 days to receive, what is the shelf life your signature muffins?
                          Asked on 6/3/2013 by Susan

                          1 answer

                          • CUSTOMER CARE

                            A:

                            Susan,our muffins should be refrigerated or frozen upon arrival. The shelf life is two weeks refrigerated or four months frozen for all of our muffins at this time.

                            Answered on 6/3/2013 by Customer Care from Medford, OR
                        • Q:

                          I just bought a LivingSocial deal for these to use for my dad for Father's Day. The deal listed flavors like Jalapeno Cheddar and Cheddar Cheese, which aren't displayed as a choice for the 4-pack. How can I get those?
                          Asked on 6/3/2013 by Andie from Baltimore, MD

                          1 answer

                          • CUSTOMER CARE

                            A:

                            Andie -- thank you for asking! We are no longer offering our Cornmeal Jalapeno Cheddar flavor of English Muffins. However, the Cheddar Cheese English Muffins will be back in stock by the end of next week!

                            Answered on 6/4/2013 by Customer Care from Medford OR
                        • Q:

                          how many calories and fat grams are in these English Muffins? also how much sodium? Thanks!
                          Asked on 2/11/2013 by DonnaD from New Jersey

                          1 answer

                        • Q:

                          Can these be frozen, used later and still be great tasting?
                          Asked on 12/30/2012 by Anonymous

                          2 answers

                          • CUSTOMER CARE

                            A:

                            Our Signature English Muffins should be refrigerated or frozen upon arrival. Shelf life is two weeks refrigerated or four months frozen.

                            Answered on 12/31/2012 by Customer Care from Medford, OR
                          • A:

                            We regularly freeze them for use later -- first split the halves. Toasting the halves thoroughly from a frozen state may be a bit challenging, but they are still tasty and we keep coming back to reorder!

                            Answered on 1/22/2013 by Jon from Ventura, CA
                        Displaying questions 1-6

                        Do you have a question about this product?